Filmmaker Ami Horowitz says antisemitism has taken hold in influential movements of both major parties, and he warns that the midterm elections will strengthen those wings. “I am generally an optimistic person, and I have become more and more pessimistic over the last few years,” Horowitz said.
Horowitz, who is Jewish, is known for videos shot on college campuses that expose hypocrisy and that he describes as darkly humorous. He also predicts that Democrats will misread their midterm victory, says Israel would be better off without U.S. military aid, and discloses that he is making a new feature film.
Ami Horowitz on antisemitism on the left and right
Horowitz says the source of antisemitism has shifted during his lifetime. When he was growing up, he said, it came from the right. Over the past 20 years, he said, it has come mostly from the left, and now it comes from both.
He portrays democratic socialists on the left and isolationists on the right as gaining political power and says neither is a fringe. “These are not groups that are being isolated by these parties,” he said. “They’re actually being celebrated by the parties, and that’s a problem.”
He calls Vice President JD Vance “a problem” for Republicans, describing Vance as the favorite for the next Republican presidential nomination. A Center Square poll conducted Oct. 5-7 by Noble Predictive Insights put Vance at 44% among Republicans and Republican-leaning independents, with Secretary of State Marco Rubio second at 18%.
Is it safe to be Jewish in America?
Horowitz insists yes. He rejects claims that Jews cannot ride the New York subway or wear a yarmulke in public, calling them hyperbolic. He also says attacks on Jews in New York are several times more frequent than a decade ago, though from a low starting point. “It’s definitely a problem, but it’s not unsafe to be Jewish in this country,” he said.
Watch: 📺 Ami On The Loose on YouTube
That data shows that hate crimes targeting Jews are increasing. New York Police Department data show that Jewish people were the targets of 181 of the city’s 325 confirmed hate crimes in the first half of 2026, or 56%. This rise in hate is what motivates Horowitz to test hostility toward Jews. In a disturbing video filmed earlier this year at San Francisco State University, he asked students for donations to fund attacks on Jewish schools, buses, and hospitals and found people willing to give. Humor helps people absorb such hatred, he said, but does not answer it.
“When it comes to fighting them, we have to fight them with every fiber of our being,” Horowitz advised.
What Horowitz says the midterms mean for 2028
Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress in this month’s elections, with 56 Senate seats and 256 House seats, according to the latest election results. And Horowitz says the Democratic Party’s hard left will read the results as proof that its candidates can win outside reliably Democratic areas.
He points to Abdul El-Sayed, the Democrat who defeated Republican Mike Rogers for Michigan’s U.S. Senate seat. President Donald Trump carried Michigan in 2024. “I think the Democrats are going to read this wrong, and I think it’s going to lead them down a path that may have them lose the presidential election,” he said. He believes that misreading will steer Democrats away from a centrist presidential nominee.
“I think the biggest winner of the election is Kamala Harris,” he said of the party’s 2024 presidential nominee.
The same Center Square poll that showed Vance leading Republicans found Harris first among Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents at 29%, ahead of California Gov. Gavin Newsom at 14%. Her support has held between 27% and 31% across four surveys since March. But Horowitz voices a parallel worry about Republicans. Rather than move toward the center, he says, the wing he calls the “mercantilist right, isolationist right” may conclude it has room to move further right.
Should the U.S. end military aid to Israel?
Horowitz says yes. He believes Israel would be better off without U.S. financial aid, and that the Jewish state could adjust if given about five years’ notice. Horowitz says Israel would keep buying American weapons, as other allies do, although incoming Senators like El-Sayed have stated they want to eliminate all military sales to Israel.
The question gained urgency on Election Day, when President Trump said in a Fox News interview that he and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had agreed to stop the aid by the end of this year. The U.S. provides Israel about $3.8 billion a year under a 10-year agreement that runs through fiscal 2028. “It would be difficult to do it tomorrow. I think Israel could survive it if it was tomorrow,” he said. Horowitz’s premise is that free aid weakens the recipient, whether a person or a country. “At the end of the day, I think Israel’s better off without it,” he said.